Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Pompano Beach Estate & Trust Litigation Lawyer
Schedule a Consultation Today! 954-491-7099

Splitting Everything Down the Middle: What Florida’s Community Property Trust Means for Married Couples

ElderPlan

Florida has always been a separate property state. What a spouse earns or buys in their own name generally stays theirs. Since 2021, though, married couples have had a way to opt into something very different. Under Florida’s Community Property Trust Act, spouses can place assets into a trust that treats everything inside it as owned equally by both.

The appeal is usually financial, but the consequences reach well beyond taxes. For families dealing with the estate of a spouse who signed one of these trusts, our Pompano Beach trust litigation attorneys often see the same pattern: a planning tool that made sense on paper becomes the center of a dispute once someone dies.

Why Couples Choose This Option

Most couples consider a community property trust because of how federal tax law treats community property at death. When one spouse passes, both halves of the community property can receive a new cost basis, which may significantly reduce capital gains taxes if the survivor later sells appreciated assets like real estate or long-held stocks. For South Florida couples holding property that has climbed in value over decades, the savings can be substantial.

The tradeoff is control. Once assets are classified as community property, the rules about who gets what at death change in ways many families do not anticipate.

What the Statute Requires

The Act is strict about formalities. Under Section 736.1503, Florida Statutes, an arrangement qualifies as a community property trust only if it:

  • Expressly declares that it is a community property trust under Florida law
  • Has at least one qualified trustee, though either or both spouses may also serve
  • Is signed by both spouses using the formalities required for executing a trust
  • Opens with a specific warning, printed in capital letters, advising the spouses that the consequences may be very extensive and that independent legal advice is strongly recommended

A document missing any of these elements may not be a community property trust at all, which can change everything about how its assets are divided.

Where the Disputes Start

Section 736.1507 provides that when a spouse dies, half of the trust’s aggregate value belongs to the survivor and cannot be controlled by the deceased spouse’s will. The other half passes under the deceased spouse’s estate plan. The statute also excludes the survivor’s half from the elective estate.

That structure creates friction in blended families. Children from a prior marriage may assume a parent’s will controls everything, only to learn that half now belongs to a stepparent. The statute also allows the trustee to make non-pro rata distributions, meaning the survivor might receive the house while the other side receives investment accounts of supposedly equal value. Valuation fights follow naturally.

A spouse may also challenge the trust itself. Section 736.1512 makes a community property trust unenforceable if it was unconscionable when made, signed involuntarily, or the product of fraud, duress, coercion, or overreaching. It is also unenforceable if the challenging spouse did not receive fair disclosure of the other spouse’s property and obligations, did not waive that disclosure in writing, and did not otherwise have notice of those finances. Notably, the lack of separate attorneys for each spouse is not enough, on its own, to defeat the trust.

A community property trust can be a smart planning decision or the opening move in years of litigation, depending on how it was drafted, disclosed, and administered. If you are a surviving spouse, a stepchild, or a trustee trying to sort out what a trust like this actually means, the Pompano Beach estate and trust litigation lawyers at Mark R. Manceri, P.A. can review the document and your options. Call our office to set up a consultation.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

© 2019 - 2026 Mark R. Manceri, P.A. All rights reserved.
This law firm website is managed by MileMark Media.