One Estate, Two Courthouses: What Happens When a Floridian Owned Property Somewhere Else

Plenty of Broward County residents keep a mountain cabin in North Carolina, a summer place up north, or a rental condo in the city where they grew up. Florida probate handles most of what they leave behind, but real estate generally answers to the law of the state where it sits. That usually means a second proceeding, called ancillary probate, in a courthouse hundreds of miles away. For Pompano Beach probate litigation lawyers, this is where otherwise simple estates start to fracture.
How the Two Proceedings Fit Together
The main administration, known as the domiciliary proceeding, takes place where the decedent lived. For a Florida resident, that means a Florida circuit court. The ancillary proceeding is a narrower case opened in the other state solely to deal with property located there.
Florida’s own statute shows how this works from the other direction. Under section 734.102, Florida Statutes, when a nonresident dies leaving assets in Florida, a representative may obtain ancillary letters here. The ancillary personal representative must post bond, publish notice to creditors, and follow procedures kept as close to an ordinary administration as possible. Once expenses and claims are paid, the court may send what remains back to the domiciliary representative or distribute it to beneficiaries. Other states run their own versions of this process, and the details vary from one to the next.
Where Friction Develops
Two courts, two sets of rules, and often two different fiduciaries create openings for delay and disagreement. Issues that frequently surface include:
- Separate creditor deadlines and notice requirements in each state, which can leave one proceeding open long after the other is ready to close
- The out-of-state court’s demand for authenticated copies of the Florida will and letters before it will act
- Limits in some states on who may serve as a fiduciary, forcing the family to appoint someone other than the named personal representative
- Duplicate legal and filing costs that reduce what beneficiaries ultimately receive
- Confusion over how the out-of-state property is valued, reported, and credited toward each beneficiary’s share
The Domicile Question
In South Florida, the most contentious ancillary disputes often begin with a more basic question: was the decedent really a Florida resident? Seasonal residents who split time between states can leave behind conflicting evidence, such as a Florida homestead exemption alongside an out-of-state voter registration. If another state claims the decedent as its own, the entire structure can flip, with that state hosting the main case and Florida playing the ancillary role. The answer can affect creditor rights, homestead protections, and even which will controls.
Beneficiaries in the Florida proceeding are not powerless. Section 733.604 requires the personal representative to file a verified inventory, to supplement it when new property or corrected values come to light, and, upon written request, to explain how inventory values were determined. Those tools help heirs track whether the out-of-state property is being handled transparently.
When an estate is stuck between a Broward courtroom and one several states away, bring the deed, the will, and any letters already issued to Mark R. Manceri, P.A. We will map out which court controls what and where the pressure points are. Our Pompano Beach probate lawyers regularly coordinate with counsel in other states so that families are not left waiting on two clocks at once.